Israel mulls reopening gyms and pools after claims of arbitrary virus closure

Knesset's Coronavirus Committee set to convene later in the day to approve outline proposed by opposition factions, which says only 2% of all COVID-19 infections are contracted at gyms and swimming pools; 'To shut down a pool during summer is madness,' says one owner
Ynet|
Getting your Trinity Audio player ready...
Israel mulls reopening its gyms and public swimming pools, shut down last week following a surge in new coronavirus cases, after people swarmed hotel pools over the weekend, prompting claims of arbitrary closures.
  • Follow Ynetnews on Facebook and Twitter

  • Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu's cabinet last week voted to shut down all gyms and public pools as well as bars, nigh clubs and event halls, as the number of COVID-19 diagnoses continues to exceed 1,000 cases a day.
    4 View gallery
    חדר כושר "אייקון פיטנס" בבאר שבע
    חדר כושר "אייקון פיטנס" בבאר שבע
    Icon Fitness gym in Be'er Sheva
    (Photo: Barel Efraim )
    Swimming pools at hotels and fitness studios, however, were allowed to stay open, prompting claims from business owners the government doesn't conduct proper research about how the virus spreads before making these decisions, which tend to have drastic financial implications.
    The Knesset's Coronavirus Committee is set to convene later on Sunday to vote on the decision to reopen all public pools and gyms after an appeal by opposition factions in the parliament. The factions presented the committee with a research, which shows that less than 2% of all coronavirus infections so far were contracted in either swimming pools or gyms.
    4 View gallery
    בריכת מלון הרודס בתל אביב
    בריכת מלון הרודס בתל אביב
    Herods Hotel in Tel Aviv
    On Saturday, scores of people swarmed the Herods hotel pool in Tel Aviv, while the neighboring Gordon public pool remained empty.
    The committee's head, MK Yifat Shasha-Biton, said in an interview with Ynet last week, that she will vote to lift the closures if the government doesn't provide any relevant data for the continued closure of gyms and swimming pools.
    "There is an arbitrary decision here – a hotel pool should be no different than an outdoor pool," said Prof. Ronit Calderon-Margalit of Hadassah School of Public Health at the Hebrew University.
    4 View gallery
    חוף ים בתל אביב
    חוף ים בתל אביב
    Overcrowded beach in Tel Aviv during the epidemic
    (Photo: Nadav Abas)
    In addition, The Swimming Pools Managers Association petitioned the High Court of Justice to allow the pools to stay open since there is no data to support the claim that the virus "can spread via contact with water."
    The petition emphasized the government's decision harms the owners of public pools and their 120,000 employees, suppliers and the swimmers who will be forced to give up their daily activities.
    President of the Swimming Pools Managers Association Nir Oz said the government's decision is nothing less than discrimination. "They reopened hotels, it is a political decision because Tourism Minister Asaf Zamir said that if hotel pools are closed, the hotels will have to shutter as well."
    Asaf Be Haim, the owner of 13 public swimming pools, also blamed the government. "All hotels sell entry tickets and let outsiders in, which for all intends and purposes makes it a public swimming pool."
    4 View gallery
    ציון הלל חבר הנהלת איגוד מרכזי ספורט ובריכות השחייה בישראל
    ציון הלל חבר הנהלת איגוד מרכזי ספורט ובריכות השחייה בישראל
    Zion Hillel
    ( Photo: Courtesy )
    Zion Hillel, the owner of seven swimming pools and two gyms said, "it is simply unfair to close public swimming pools and allow hotel pools to remain open. Is it economically correct to close down public swimming pools and not those in hotels? We are at the peak of the summer season and even without the closure things were bad, since the government canceled all summer camps, parties and events."
    According to Hillel, he had to let go no less than 48 employees. "I had tears in my eyes, these are minimum wage employees who live from paycheck to paycheck. To shut down a pool during summer is madness. It hurts, it is simply unbelievable."
    2Comments
    add comment
    The commenter agrees to the privacy policy of Ynet News and agrees not to submit comments that violate the terms of use, including incitement, libel and expressions that exceed the accepted norms of freedom of speech.
    2.
    another corona flip flop
    The government needs to be closing things that do not affect the economy to much not open more and more place, have we learned nothing from the rushed opening of the econony to satisfy public demand and business? At a public pool social distancing and mask wearing are both physically impossible because to many people want to come. Hotels should not be allowed to open their pools to the public but its much more likley social distancing will be possible at a hotel pool open only to guests. The government should also be closing the overcrowded beaches where again social distancing and mask wesring is impossible, closing beaches will not affect the economy in any significant way apart from a few ice cream stalls and beach restraunts so this can be done easily. Closing the beaches will also do more to scare people nto getting their act together than anything else because Israelis love the beach. As for gyms, most certainly they should be closed, they are confined spaces, people wander round from one machine to another, equipment does not get wiped down everytime somebody stops using it and wearing of masks is actually dangerous so gyms should be kept closed. Time for the government to stop running scared and take control and stop the spread of this virus just like they did when the lockdown was introduced because right now they are all running around like headless chickens whilst the virus is spreading like wildfire.
    zionist forever| 07.13.20
    00
    add comment
    The commenter agrees to the privacy policy of Ynet News and agrees not to submit comments that violate the terms of use, including incitement, libel and expressions that exceed the accepted norms of freedom of speech.
    1.
    & when there r deaths & they r sued they will demand that..
    the State indemnify them against loses. These people are so selfish!
    07.12.20
    00
    add comment
    The commenter agrees to the privacy policy of Ynet News and agrees not to submit comments that violate the terms of use, including incitement, libel and expressions that exceed the accepted norms of freedom of speech.
    ""