Israel needs an honest conversation with its superspreaders

Opinion: The precarious pandemic situation stems from the government's lack of communication with the Arab and ultra-Orthodox sectors, which constitute the most infections and as a result pose the greatest risk to national stability
Sarit Rosenblum|
Getting your Trinity Audio player ready...
For many weeks now, Israel has been categorized as a "red" country due to its high coronavirus infection rates. But that sweeping designation does not reflect the true state of affairs.
  • Follow Ynetnews on Facebook and Twitter

  • According to the data presented last week to ministers, almost half of Israel's local authorities are actually "green" due to their low infection rates.
    5 View gallery
    מתפללים בכותל בתשעה באב
    מתפללים בכותל בתשעה באב
    Ultra-Orthodox men praying at the Western Wall during the coronavirus pandemic
    (Photo: Reuters)
    According to the same data, COVID-19 is actually rampant in just 20 of Israel's hundreds of cities and local councils; the second coronavirus wave is the result of outbreaks in two sectors - the Arab and ultra-Orthodox communities.
    5 View gallery
    בדיקות קורונה ברמת השרון
    בדיקות קורונה ברמת השרון
    Coronavirus testing in Ramat Hasharon
    (Photo: AFP)
    Almost 40% of new coronavirus patients are ultra-Orthodox and 20% are Arab. The figures may even be higher and not properly reflect the true picture, because the members of the ultra-Orthodox community rarely get tested.
    Ultra-Orthodox Israelis form a disproportionate percentage of new coronavirus infection s- some would say they constitute more than 50% of new infections while comprising just 10% or so of the overall population.
    It is no coincidence therefore that the "red" localities are mainly ultra-Orthodox and Arab areas.
    5 View gallery
    הפגנה של תושבי רוממה במחאה על הסגר שהוטל על השכונה
    הפגנה של תושבי רוממה במחאה על הסגר שהוטל על השכונה
    Ultra-Orthodox men clash with police during protest against the closure of a Haredi neighborhood in Jerusalem
    (Photo: Shalev Shalom)
    Last week, the Health Ministry published a survey showing the public's attitudes towards the coronavirus pandemic, which revealed a grim reality.
    In the ultra-Orthodox sector, 31% of respondents said they are refraining from getting tested for fear they may need to enter isolation. More than 40% of those surveyed said they attended public gatherings that violated Health Ministry regulations. One third said they personally know someone who has violated isolation directives.
    The high infection rate among the ultra-Orthodox is not just the result of poverty and overcrowding, it also stems from a severe lack of trust in Israel's government.
    It could even be seen as a form of sectoral protest, a kind of collective middle finger to the "Man," whom they see as ignoring their needs, their customs and their way of life.
    5 View gallery
    מחאה חרדים רוממה ירושלים
    מחאה חרדים רוממה ירושלים
    Ultra-Orthodox men protest against the closure of a Haredi neighborhood in Jerusalem
    (Photo: Alex Kolomoyski)
    ultra-Orthodox Israelis feel deprived. They don't understand why thousands can amass outside the prime minister's residence in Jerusalem to protest, while they are not allowed to gather in synagogues to pray or have any other public gathering.
    This is what they are rebelling against.
    Despite the disturbing figures regarding the infection rate among the Ultra-Orthodox, the government has thus far done nothing to help them get through the pandemic with dignity.
    Instead of lecturing, we need dialogue. The sector must be offered the tools to stem further infections while being able to adhere to custom and shown respect.
    And if that doesn't work, the country must really crack down on the community and fully enforce the virus regulations.
    5 View gallery
    Coronavirus tests in the Arab village of Tamra
    Coronavirus tests in the Arab village of Tamra
    Coronavirus tests in the Arab village of Tamra
    (Photo: AFP)
    The days we have left before the government decides to tighten restrictions for everyone must be used not to speak to the citizens of the State of Tel Aviv, but to address the sector whose members are at the heart of the contagion.
    For if the contagion in the sector is not dealt with quickly and efficiently, the entire State of Israel will pay the price.
    5Comments
    add comment
    The commenter agrees to the privacy policy of Ynet News and agrees not to submit comments that violate the terms of use, including incitement, libel and expressions that exceed the accepted norms of freedom of speech.
    4.
    Do the superspreaders want to have a conversation?
    Here is an old joke: - "How many psychiatrists does it take to change a light bulb?" - "None. The bulb needs to want to change!" You can't have a conversation with someone who refuses to take talk to you, let alone take you seriously. Israel's problem is that it has been nurturing segments of population which wants it gone, one way or another.
    Igor| 08.25.20
    71
    add comment
    The commenter agrees to the privacy policy of Ynet News and agrees not to submit comments that violate the terms of use, including incitement, libel and expressions that exceed the accepted norms of freedom of speech.
    3.
    It's getting too late
    The excuses for the haredi behavior are very thin. They know very well what the consequences of their actions are, but simply don't believe they owe the state anything. They also make up a large number of people who regularly visit hospitals, carrying their Covid (you're only measured for temperature and for many it's asymptomatic) with them. It's hard to imagine what has happened to this country's governing bodies that they have for several months now stood back and done absolutely nothing to allay the people's fears. Bets are on that there is more fear than there are objectors to lockdown for their own selfish reasons. And then of course there's a government prepared to spend billions on elections to gain supremacy but don't provide for those who need financial age so they can withstand restrictions or lockdown - as in most other countries. We are in Kafkaesque nightmare territory already. Sitting ducks while Neroiyahu fiddles as the country burns. If we get another 10000 infections something's going to blow. We're becoming untouchables as we are one of the few countries to do absolutely nothing to help stem this contagion. It's worse than shameful. I do not know how this crime minister dares show his face. He's clearly lost his marbles and can no longer be trusted to do what is right for the citizens of this country. Disgraceful, shameful and actually - and most definitely abnormal.
    pgr| 08.25.20
    127
    add comment
    The commenter agrees to the privacy policy of Ynet News and agrees not to submit comments that violate the terms of use, including incitement, libel and expressions that exceed the accepted norms of freedom of speech.
    2.
    Racism and bigotry
    What an ugly article. Not a single mention of leftist protestorsor secular drunkards rebelling maskless on the streets.
    Joseph| 08.25.20
    916
    add comment
    The commenter agrees to the privacy policy of Ynet News and agrees not to submit comments that violate the terms of use, including incitement, libel and expressions that exceed the accepted norms of freedom of speech.
    Load more talkbacks
    ""