Israel's proposed change to Law of Return raises opposition

Netanyahu asks for compromise to appease future coalition partners as deadline to form government looms; compromise considered by Likud would make immigrants who are 3rd generation removed from Jewish grandparents, residents but no citizens of the country
Kobe Nachshoni|
A change demanded by members of the incoming coalition, limiting the scope of immigration under the Law of Return, is causing outrage among some in political, religious and social circles.
  • Follow Ynetnews on Facebook and Twitter

  • As part of their conditions to join a Netanyahu led government, ultra-Orthodox parties and the religious nationalist Religious Zionist party have demanded that people two-generations removed from Jewish ancestry, be no longer eligible for Israeli citizenship under the law.
    4 View gallery
    בנימין נתניהו  ואריה דרעי    במליאת הכנסת
    בנימין נתניהו  ואריה דרעי    במליאת הכנסת
    Benjamin Netanyahu and Aryeh Deri
    (Photo: AFP )
    The Law of Return was enacted in 1950, as part of Israel's national mission to be a safe haven from prosecution, for Jews all over the world and present Israel as a homeland for the Jews.
    With less than a week left for the mandate given to Netanyahu to form his new government, he has yet to resolve the matter that will effect Israel's relations with the Jewish diaspora.
    The demand to change the law came after the pending coalition partners said that Israel has a large population of non-Jews, alluding predominately to immigrants from former Soviet republics, and that they pose a threat to the Jewish character of the state.
    4 View gallery
    פליטים מאוקראינה נוחתים בישראל
    פליטים מאוקראינה נוחתים בישראל
    Immigrants from Ukraine arrive after Russian invasion
    (Photo: Friendship Fund )
    According to the Central Bureau of Statistics, one in four immigrants is not Jewish.
    They have also demanded to grant the Orthodox Rabbinate in Israel with the sole authority to carry out conversions and to recognize and approve conversions to Judaism conducted abroad.
    If the decision of who is a Jew, is left in the hands of the Rabbinate alone, Conservative and Reform Jewish conversions will likely not be recognized by the state, for the purpose of citizenship.
    Netanyahu's Likud was reported to be considering a compromise that would allow third generation removed immigrants to become permanent residents of Israel but not be given citizenship.
    Activist Alex Rif who is an advocate for the rights of immigrants from the former Soviet Union, said such legislation would be a grave mistake.
    4 View gallery
    אלקס ריף
    אלקס ריף
    Alex Rif
    (Photo: Tal Shahar)
    “This hurts the essence of the Jewish people,” she said adding that although the religious parties are now targeting immigrants from Ukraine and Russia, the effects could be felt in the U.S., France and Brazil - suffering currently from a rise in antisemitism.
    “The Law of Return as it stands is needed and brings Jewish people closer together, she said. "We need to solve the issue of immigration.”
    Outgoing tourism minister Yoel Razvozov, himself an immigrant, criticized the proposed compromise. “The new compromise to the law of return is shameful to all of those who have immigrated to Israel,"
    4 View gallery
    שר התיירות יואל רזבוזוב באירוע חגיגות יום העצמאות לאיחוד האמירויות
    שר התיירות יואל רזבוזוב באירוע חגיגות יום העצמאות לאיחוד האמירויות
    Tourism Minister Yoel Razvozov
    (Photo: Yair Sagi)
    Israel’s Movement for Reform and Progressive Judaism also criticized the decision. “A change to the law of return will make Israel cease to be the state of the entire Jewish people,” it said. “The compromise wanting to make grandchildren of Jewish descent to permanent residents is wrong.”
    “It means that grandchildren who were born to Jewish people from abroad and immigrated, including IDF soldiers, will be second-class citizens. They will be obligated to pay taxes and serve in the military – but be deprived citizenship and immigration aid. “These steps will bring about a unpreparable rift with the Jewish world and cause fewer to chose to immigrate. The incoming government should open Israel’s gates to all Jewish people who want to take part in this country, instead of harming them,” the Reform movement said.
    Comments
    The commenter agrees to the privacy policy of Ynet News and agrees not to submit comments that violate the terms of use, including incitement, libel and expressions that exceed the accepted norms of freedom of speech.
    ""