Bringing back Israelis on board coronavirus-hit ship is danger to public safety

Analysis: As time goes by, more and more passengers aboard the Diamond Princess cruise liner test positive for the deadly virus, including 3 out of the 15 Israelis; returning them to Israel could lead to the disease spreading further
Dr. Itay Gal|
Getting your Trinity Audio player ready...
As the number of cases on board the coronavirus-hit ship off the Japanese coast continues to soar, the issue of releasing the passengers who have not yet been diagnosed with the disease is stirring controversy around the world.
  • Follow Ynetnews on Facebook and Twitter
  • So far, 355 passengers out of 3,711 aboard the Diamond Princess cruise liner have been diagnosed with the virus, including three Israelis (out of 15 on board).
    3 View gallery
    ספינת הקורונה ביפן
    ספינת הקורונה ביפן
    The Diamond Princess cruise liner
    (Photo: AP)
    Three countries have already announced their intentions to bring back their nationals on board the liner.
    As of Sunday, the death toll of the coronavirus stands at 1,665, and at least 69,270 of people are reported to have been infected with the pathogen globally, despite efforts to quarantine the disease and mitigate its spread.
    "Even with precautions such as protective suits, the release of the passengers from the ship will probably result in others being infected," said Dr. Shimon Edelstein, director of the infectious diseases unit at Ziv Medical Center in Safed.
    "It is enough for one of the passengers flying back home to go to the plane's bathroom, to infect everyone who would use the bathroom afterwards. We still don't know enough about the coronavirus, but we do know it's highly contagious and that there is still no cure or vaccine available.
    In this situation, releasing the passengers could cause mass spread [of the disease] in many countries."
    According to Edelstein, the cruise ship is a viral hotbed, in which getting infected is almost inevitable.
    3 View gallery
    ספינת הקורונה דיימונד פרינסס יפן
    ספינת הקורונה דיימונד פרינסס יפן
    American passengers from the Diamond Princess being evacuated
    (Photo: Reuters)
    "The passenger's situation pains me. They are trapped in their rooms and are only allowed to go on deck for an hour a day, as more and more people around them get infected. However, the quarantine wasn't set for nothing, but for considerations of danger to public health."
    According to data currently available, the coronavirus spreads mostly through saliva. For instance, if a person infected with the virus sneezes, those standing as far as 1.8 meters (5'9 feet) from him or her, would most likely catch the virus.
    Although a lot is still unknown about the virus, there are no reports of infections through ventilation or air conditioning systems.
    However, experts around the world have already warned the rate of the disease's spread at the cruise liner is the world's biggest and fastest so far, and the cause has not yet been clarified.
    The major concern that prevents authorities from moving passengers from the ship to an isolation camp is that during this transfer, further mass contagion may occur between the passengers, as well as between passengers and medical personnel.
    3 View gallery
    ספינת הקורונה ביפן
    ספינת הקורונה ביפן
    A passenger aboard the Diamon Princess cruise liner
    (Photo: AP)
    The U.S. Embassy in Japan announced on Saturday that it will fly back 400 of its citizens aboard the liner, anchored in the Yokohama port, south of Tokyo.
    Israel also intends on rescuing its nationals on deck.
    The Foreign Ministry estimates the Israelis who have not been diagnosed with the virus are set to disembark the ship when the quarantine period expires on Wednesday or Thursday, and will then be free to leave.
    One of the options considered is to bring them to Israel on a special plane after being released from quarantine, taking into account those carrying the coronavirus will not be brought back.
    Despite the efforts to curb the disease's spread aboard the Diamond Princess, it seems that the number of cases will only continue to soar due to its rapid spread.
    Tests in China have shown that the virus can survive for days on different surfaces, can be transferred through small saliva particles and that the use of masks fails to protect against potential infection.
    One of the options considered is to take the passengers to an isolation camp near the port where the ship is docked. However, setting up such a camp will take many days and will involve high costs and put medical staff on (as well as off) board at risk of getting infected.
    10Comments
    add comment
    The commenter agrees to the privacy policy of Ynet News and agrees not to submit comments that violate the terms of use, including incitement, libel and expressions that exceed the accepted norms of freedom of speech.
    12.
    Ignorance and irresponsibility vs common sense
    It's enough to despair for humanity seeing some of the comments. One wonders why governments spend so much on basic education as it clearly has little impact on those who would argue that 15 people stuck in an unenviable situation should have precedence over the good of 9 million. Confinement of the contagion area is the best that medicine has for as long as scientists are desperately trying to learn more about this new and deadly "plague." It is horrible and unfortunate for the people who found themselves in the thick of it. But it is a whole lot more horrible if just one of those people - as happened on that ship - brings it to others, who then infect several others and so it goes until the medical systems cannot possibly cope. Just putting them together in a plane won't stop others who haven't been infected from being infected by one carrier. As the doctors say, it survives in the planes toilets, it survives in the seats and they don't know for how long or how to kill it. Fools is about the kindest word that can be applied to people who rattle off garbage knowing nothing. Fools of the government who would prefer not to be threatened by 15 families politically and risk the rest of the country for it. Ego defeats all. Stupidity reigns.
    pgr| 02.18.20
    04
    add comment
    The commenter agrees to the privacy policy of Ynet News and agrees not to submit comments that violate the terms of use, including incitement, libel and expressions that exceed the accepted norms of freedom of speech.
    11.
    Coronavirus - Diamond Princess cruise ship - Israelis
    Has anyone given it a thought that there may be are some individuals that are carriers of the virus. Carriers that do not show symptoms, but only have the germs in their body and passing it around. This is specifically the reason that the Israeli citizens onboard the cruise ship need to remain in quarantine until time shows them to be healthy and then bring them back home and continue to be watched. After all, 15 Israelis vs. 6 (?) million Israelis.
    Barbara| 02.17.20
    25
    add comment
    The commenter agrees to the privacy policy of Ynet News and agrees not to submit comments that violate the terms of use, including incitement, libel and expressions that exceed the accepted norms of freedom of speech.
    10.
    Heads up to dumb selfish Israelis.....
    You travel the garbage cans of the world because you fell entitled all the while eating their vile tinif. You feel 'suffocated' in poor little Israel, so when you get into a stir you expect poor little Israel to launch an Entebbe style rescue to get you out of your mess. When you leave Israel youre on your own. The government ie all the other Israelis owe you nothing. You ought to know that, but no, being the selfish little creeps that you have been taught to be you dont know that. The new post Zionist Israel has no future. Selfish entitled brats have become your legacy.
    Al| 02.17.20
    01
    add comment
    The commenter agrees to the privacy policy of Ynet News and agrees not to submit comments that violate the terms of use, including incitement, libel and expressions that exceed the accepted norms of freedom of speech.
    Load more talkbacks
    ""