The state of New York will introduce a new bill on December 15 prohibiting the sale of dogs, cats and rabbits. At first glance, the law appears to be a positive step aimed at reducing cruel industrial breeding practices and encouraging adoptions from shelters and organizations. However, not everyone is pleased.
Known as the "Puppy Mill Pipeline Act," the legislation has sparked public debate, with critics warning of economic harm that could lead to store closures and a rise in shady, unregulated markets. Supporters, on the other hand, see it as a humane measure that protects animals and benefits consumers.
Governor Kathy Hochul and Attorney General Letitia James explained that the law aims to cut off the "puppy mill pipeline" — the supply chain of animals bred in commercial "puppy mills," often in overcrowded and neglectful conditions, prioritizing profit over animal welfare.
These mills, mainly located in the Midwest, rely on brokers, auctions and transporters to deliver animals to pet stores across the state.
The law's goals include ending the suffering of animals born in such conditions and preventing consumers from incurring high veterinary expenses due to the genetic and health problems common in commercially bred pets. It also encourages partnerships between pet stores and shelters, allowing stores to showcase animals for adoption in exchange for fees from the organizations.
Supporters believe the initiative will reduce overcrowding in shelters and decrease euthanasia rates. "This isn’t just a law; it’s about saving lives," said Board Chairman of the New York Humane Association Harold Hovel, who actively promoted the legislation for years. "It opens the door to adoptions and gives animals a chance at better lives."
However, not everyone agrees. Pet store owners warn of significant harm to their businesses, claiming the law will push customers to unregulated online markets where animal sources are harder to monitor. They argue the law merely shifts the problem elsewhere, potentially making it worse.
Last month, pet store owners in the southern part of the state filed a lawsuit seeking to delay the law’s implementation, arguing it lacks sufficient evidence to improve animal welfare. They also claimed it would force many stores to close, jeopardizing the livelihoods of hundreds of workers. However, legal experts suggest it’s unlikely the courts will intervene in this policy matter.
Get the Ynetnews app on your smartphone: Google Play: https://bit.ly/4eJ37pE | Apple App Store: https://bit.ly/3ZL7iNv
Once the law is enacted, stores continuing to sell dogs, cats or rabbits could face fines of up to $1,000 per violation.
New York will join states like Illinois, Maryland, Maine, Washington and California, which have already implemented similar laws, positioning itself as a leader in the fight against commercial breeding.